Selasa, 12 Juli 2011

Where Are the Helmets in the Home Run Derby?

Last night I returned home from a lovely dinner with my injury prevention colleagues to a sight that really caught me by surprise. My husband was watching the Major League Baseball (MLB) Home Run Derby. I tuned in for a moment before turning to him and asking, "Why aren't they wearing helmets?" I think we are all accustomed to seeing players in their batting helmets, so this looked strange to me- especially in contrast to the catcher, who was dressed in full protective gear. My husband informed me that helmets are not necessary because the pitches are much slower. However- I would disagree (and this is not the first time I have critiqued professional sports and their commitment to protecting players from head injuries).

First of all, concussions (which we must remember are a traumatic brain injury!) do not only occur when the ball is traveling 100 MPH. Therefore, a slower pitch does not equal safety. The catcher still wore full protective gear. The pitcher stood behind protective netting. So on some level it is acknowledged that hazards still exist at the Home Run Derby.

In addition, concussions (or more serious injuries) can happen even when you are not the batter. Therefore, helmets protect you when you are on deck, warming up, or coaching from the sidelines. Home Run Derby participants are still at risk for injury when they are not at bat. This is a lesson that many in baseball know far too well. In 2007, a minor league first base coach was killed when he was hit in the head with a line drive. This tragic accident resulted in a change in policy regarding required head protection for first and third base coaches.

Speaking of policy, I find it strange that their batting helmet practices vary based on the speed of the pitch. This is not an acceptable strategy in other areas of injury prevention, so why is that the strategy here? We don't tell people to only wear seatbelts if they are planning to drive faster than 40 MPH. We don't tell people to only avoid texting and driving if they are on the highway. The MLB seems to be accepting a high level of risk for their players in this context. This is especially surprising since MLB and the MLB Players Association have taken steps to prioritize safety regarding head injuries. They recently implemented a universal concussion policy (which went into effect on Opening Day 2011). The new policy dictates both how concussions are initially treated and when player/umpires are allowed to return to play. The most substantial change is the creation of a 7-day disabled list to allow players an appropriate amount of time to heal after a concussion. They are also introducing reinforced helmets that can withstand 100 MPH fastballs.

While the safety of the players is paramount, this discussion is also important because MLB players are role models. Therefore, it is important that they model acceptance and proper usage of personal protective equipment. If you looked at the stadium crowd at the Derby (and the lucky few invited to catch balls in the outfield), it was mostly kids. If the MLB and the players do not provide leadership on safety policies and equipment, it could have larger public health effects on the audiences that model their behavior (so don't get me started on the chewing tobacco issue).

Therefore, I strongly encourage MLB to review their policies regarding personal protective equipment and the grey "safe" areas they have identified, like the Home Run Derby. It appears to be a relaxed, fun event during the all-star break but in reality, they are unnecessarily putting the safety of their players at risk.

Selasa, 31 Mei 2011

Google Continues to Use its Power for Public Health Good


Yesterday, Google announced its new surveillance system for Dengue Fever. Dengue Fever is a disease caused by four related viruses spread by a particular species of mosquito. It can cause high fever, rash, muscle and joint pain, and in severe cases- bleeding, a sudden drop in blood pressure (shock) and death. Millions of cases of Dengue infection occur worldwide each year. Most often, dengue fever occurs in urban areas of tropical and subtropical regions.

The system is similar to that which was previously released as their Google Flu Trends program. These systems use search queries within Google (for example those that enter the disease's name and/or symptoms) to identify trends. The Dengue system also takes advantage of a new feature called Google Correlate, which shows previously unknown correlations between search terms. These correlations allow researchers to model real world behaviors by examining internet search trends. For those who may be skeptical of this model, you should check out a publication (co-authored by Google and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention-CDC) in the 2009 Nature Journal . The article reports that "because relative frequencies of certain queries were highly correlated with the percentage of physician visits in which a patient presents with influenza-like symptoms, we can accurately estimate the current level of weekly influenza activity in each region of the United States, with a reporting lag of about one day."

This is a pretty exciting addition to public health surveillance (where the goal is systematic, ongoing, data collection that is used to monitor trends, identify priorities, direct resources, identify emerging hazards, and evaluate interventions).

This is not the first time that Google has jumped into the public health field with an impressive contribution. In 2010, Google searches related to suicide started appearing with a message guiding users to the toll-free number for the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline. The number is 1-800-273-8255. Triggered by searches such as "I want to die" or "ways to commit suicide," the number is listed next to an icon of a red telephone, at the top of the search results.

The addition of the Lifeline number came shortly after (at the suggestion of a Google user), the company started displaying the hotline for the American Association of Poison Control Centers after searches for "poison emergency."

These cases of Google's work in public health are great examples of effective health communication and public health principles:
  • Identifying the primary channels through which your audience searches for health information (more and more are utilizing the internet) and delivering accurate and effective information and/or interventions via those channels.
  • Maximizing data driven surveillance systems- using existing data (e.g., internet searches) to identify public health trends.
  • Building strong partnerships (as evidenced by the publication by Google and CDC) CDC has partnered with a company with specific expertise and resources in an area that can be invaluable to their work.

Selasa, 03 Mei 2011

From The West Wing to the National Health Care Debate

Anyone who knows me well knows that "The American President" is one of my favorite movies. If it is a favorite of yours as well, you may recognize that the actress who plays Press Secretary Robin McCall also plays National Security Advisor Dr. Nancy McNally in "The West Wing". The actress is Anna Deavere Smith.

This week in my "Qualitative Research Methods in Community Health" class, we discussed ethnography. Specifically we discussed Ms. Smith's work as an example of performance ethnography. For over a decade, she has interviewed people across the country and used the "data" to develop a one-woman show. Her newest play is called "Let Me Down Easy" and its goal is to show the human side of the national health care debate. I highly recommend viewing the 10-minute excerpt and interview here.

I'm so sorry that I missed her play when it came to Philadelphia earlier this year because I think it is an amazing example of the richness of data collected using qualitative methods. It is often argued that qualitative methods are too "soft" and limited in view. I've heard them described as "basically just journalism". However, I would argue that qualitative methods are essential to the success of public health.

Instead of surveys and databases, these methods collect data via interview, discussion, and observation. The research is meant to discover the complex relationship between personal and social meaning, individual and cultural practices, and the material environment or context. In contrast to what we have learned since grade school science about the scientific method and generalizability of findings- here the focus is on obtaining a deeper understanding of a population or phenomenon.

Ms. Smith conducted over 300 interviews for "Let Me Down Easy" and ultimately condensed her findings to show the experience of contemporary health care through the eyes of 20 individuals. These kinds of stories are incredibly powerful in public health. They open our eyes to challenges that we never would have found via survey...because we wouldn't have known to ask the right questions. They allow us to share stories with policymakers so they can see the impact of their decisions beyond the sterile statistics often cited. They can allow us to explore experiences or illnesses that occur in too small a population to survey.

Ideally, quantitative and qualitative methods should be used together to create the strongest public health research design possible. It should not be us vs. them...but instead a joint effort. I encourage us all to see the human side of health care reform when Ms. Smith's play airs on PBS "Great Performances" next season.

Sabtu, 26 Maret 2011

"This is Public Health" is now an iPhone Application!


In March 2011, the Association of Schools of Public Health (ASPH) launched a new This Is Public Health (TIPH) iPhone application. It is available via the Apple itunes store. “This innovative application will allow users to digitally place an image of the TIPH sticker in photographs on their mobile device, so they no longer need to have physical stickers with them everywhere they go in order to participate in the campaign.”

The "This is Public Health" campaign was first piloted during the 2008 National Public Health Week.
The TIPH campaign was developed to achieve the following objectives:
  • Increase awareness about public health and the important role public health plays in our daily lives.
  • Position Schools of Public Health as innovative/effective leaders in public health outreach and education.
  • Engage new audiences, including policymakers and funders, in a dialogue about the importance of supporting public health.
  • Attract and inspire the next generation of public health professionals through non-traditional engagement tools.
The campaign uses stickers with the slogan "This is Public Health" placed in locations around the world to help reach its goals.

The campaign's website clearly shows the reach of the campaign- over 1,000 public health practice organizations, individuals, and other academic institutions in over 45 countries have joined the campaign. But of course (as always), I'm interested in seeing an evaluation of the campaign. It was unclear to me from the website how they define their target audience. I was not sure if they wanted to "increase awareness" of public health among "participants" of the campaign (i.e., those giving out the stickers) or among the general public (i.e., those seeing the stickers in various locations). I was able to track down an evaluation report from September 2009 (which covered the first year of the project). For purposes of this report, data was collected from program participants (defined as those that requested stickers or the campaign video). Both qualitative and quantitative data was collected via phone interviews, feedback from public health groups and individuals, a review of program data and statistics, and an online survey. Here are some key findings:
  • The majority of participants [32.7%] learned about the campaign through the ASPH website.
  • Educating the general public about public health, increasing awareness about careers in public health and increasing the understanding of the work of a particular institution were the top three goals of those who executed the campaign locally.
  • When asked to rate on a scale of 1-10 how effective the “This Is Public Health” materials were in achieving their campaign goals, nearly a quarter [23.8%] gave the materials a 10, citing them as “very helpful” and over three-quarters of the respondents rated the effectiveness a 7 or higher.
  • Simplicity and ease of use were what most campaign participants liked best about the “This Is Public Health” campaign.
  • Nearly all respondents [92.1%] said that they were likely to recommend the campaign to colleagues in the public health community with almost 70% saying they were “very likely” to do so.
Interestingly, some areas of mixed review were around the program's website, flickr group (pictures), and interactive google maps. There was some concern that keeping all the program materials online because it excluded those without Internet access. In addition, the adoption of flickr and maps depended on the "tech savviness" of the participants. So seeing that their newest addition is an iPhone application, it will be interesting to see which groups of participants are the earliest adopters of the technology. I look forward to seeing the next evaluation report!

Selasa, 23 November 2010

Text Messages and Public Health: Can They Remove Barriers for "Calling" 9-1-1?

Text messages are a great time saver. You do not have to have a long conversation with someone...instead you can just send a quick message like "I made it home safe!" or "Can you pick up milk on your way home?" These text messages work well to support our busy lives, but can they also be incorporated into effective public health interventions and systems?

This week, the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) announced that it is looking into letting citizens report crimes via text message. An article posted by Wired discusses the possibility and highlights some of the "barriers" that this new strategy could help to address. First and foremost, it could allow citizens to report a crime without being overheard if they were in dangerous situations (e.g., kidnapping, robbery). The FCC specifically pointed to the 2007 shootings at VirginiaTech and reported that texts could have allowed emergency personnel to respond more quickly and with a better understanding of the circumstances inside the campus buildings.

While at first glance, it may seem surprising to use text messaging for 9-1-1 reporting (due to potential logistical considerations and challenges), it would not be the first time that texts were being integrated into public health interventions and emergency response systems. For example:

  • Text messages are used to disseminate key health messages to various priority populations. E.g., The Text4Baby campaign allows mothers to self select into their program by texting "Baby" to the program number. The mothers then receive weekly text messages (timed to their due date or baby's birth day) regarding key health issues for their babies (e.g., nutrition, immunizations, etc).
  • Many workplaces and college campuses have signed up for emergency response systems that will send out automatic alerts to email and phones (via text message) during a crisis (e.g., shooter on site).
In the case of using text messages for "calling" 9-1-1, I wonder about how texts could influence a well documented social psychology barrier to calling for help. Those of you that took a social psychology course in college may remember the name "Kitty Genovese". She was a woman who was murdered outside her home in Queens, NY in 1964. At least one dozen people heard or observed her attack (lasting approximately 30 minutes), but there was much delay in anyone calling for help. A NY Times article running two weeks after her death was entitled, "Thirty-Eight Who Saw Murder Didn't Call Police". This case is widely discussed as an example of the "Bystander Effect", which is used to explain why many people do not help in emergency situations when others are present. Some hypotheses about the effect are that we just do what others are doing (i.e., nothing to help), we assume someone else is already calling/helping, or we assume that others are more qualified to help. Perhaps it is also too much trouble to call 9-1-1? They require a lot of information, we have to stay on the phone, etc. Perhaps a more "passive" option to report the information (like text messaging) would decrease resistance and the bystander effect?

In addition to the great potential with this strategy, there are also several barriers that must be addressed in the planning:
  • Costs (equipment, training, staffing)
  • Regulation and Oversight: Will text message support be required or voluntary at emergency centers? Who will conduct a formative and ongoing evaluation of the system?
  • Interpretation of messages: Operators will need special training to (quickly) interpret and respond to text messages. Texts are often written in short hand, so you would need someone very skilled to decipher them accurately. It may also be time consuming to support the texting back and forth that may be required to receive all relevant information from the "caller" in order to dispatch an appropriate response.
Even with the barriers noted above, it does seem like text messages are a viable option to consider in order to increase timely and safe 9-1-1 reporting. However, the 9-1-1 system will need to think critically to develop the type of infrastructure that can keep up with our ever changing and expanding communication technology.

Senin, 15 November 2010

No Matter How Graphic The Images, Fear Based Messages Will Continue To Be Ineffective For Prevention

All over the news in the past week, we have seen samples of the new graphic images being proposed for addition to cigarette packages. They include corpses and people dying of cancer. However, just because these images and warnings are larger and more graphic, does not mean that they will be effective in smoking prevention.

A story ran today on Boston.com called "Will graphic cigarette warnings help- or hurt?" Two experts in tobacco prevention are quoted regarding their concerns about the new images. Gregory Connelly of the Harvard School of Public Health points to the results coming from Canada after using similar images. Smokers there simply purchased sleeves to cover up the images on their cigarette packs. Also, the smoking rate did not go down. The second expert is a wonderful professor of mine from the Boston University School of Public Health, Dr. Michael Siegel. Dr. Siegel writes regularly regarding this topic on his blog, "The Rest of the Story: Tobacco Analysis and Commentary". In the Boston.com article, he states "I do not actually think it's going to have much of an impact". His argument- the images are too late. The smokers are seeing the images after they have already purchased cigarettes. And (drum roll please....) people already know smoking is bad for them.

As someone who grew up during the "This is your brain. This is your brain on drugs. Any questions?" era...I wonder why we have not made much progress since then? Numerous studies have shown that scare tactics (or fear appeals) are not effective for preventing or producing sustained reductions of Alcohol, Tobacco, or other Drug use among youth. In addition to the issues outlined above, there is another problem with the fear based approach:

Although the fear based messages may increase knowledge (e.g., if they did not know it already, smokers will learn that cigarettes are bad for them from the graphic images)- knowledge does not equal behavior change. Especially when you are dealing with an addictive behavior. Addictive behaviors like smoking and drug use are impacted by much more than a rational weighing of pros and cons. There is the biological component of addiction, local-state-national prevention policies, social norms around the behavior, consequences experienced (or not experienced), ease of access to the substance, social support for quiting, money to support the addiction, etc. As you can see, knowledge alone will not change this kind of complex behavior.

Many of the most successful prevention strategies around this and other public health issues will continue to be a refocus from increasing individual knowledge to changing an environment that supports the behavior. In other words, laws that create smoke-free workplaces and crack down on establishments that sell cigarettes to underage kids will always be more effective at keeping the population healthy versus trying to educate (or scare) one individual at a time.

Senin, 08 November 2010

Kids, Gender Identity, and Bullying: Moms Fight Back

Last week on Facebook, no less than ten friends posted a link to the Nerdy Apple Bottom website post "My son is gay". The post was written by the mother of a 5-year old boy who dressed as Daphne (from Scooby Doo) for Halloween. She talks about his arrival at school in his costume and the harsh reaction received...mostly from other parents. She documents her internal reaction to this reception, which prompted much discussion and cheering among my Facebook friends:

"If you think that me allowing my son to be a female character for Halloween is somehow going to 'make' him gay, then you are an idiot. Firstly, what a ridiculous concept. Secondly, if my son is gay, OK. I will love him no less. Thirdly, I am not worried that your son will grow up to be an actual ninja so back off".

As of tonight, this post had 41,311 comments.

Coincidentally, the November 15th edition of People Magazine runs a story called "A Tale of Acceptance". The story profiles a Seattle mother named Cheryl Kilodavis who also has a 5-year old son that likes to dress up as a girl character. When the behavior began three years ago, she and her husband discussed it and decided to let him dress how he liked. In order to help other kids accept him, Cheryl decided to write a children's story. She calls her self-published book, "My Princess Boy".

Cheryl first shared the book at her son's school. The vice principal loved it and put copies in all the classes. Cheryl soon had orders from nine other schools and now that there has been so much press coverage, the family is searching for a publisher and trying to keep up with the book requests.

Of course, not all of the press has been positive. A New York Times article late last week discussed some therapists' concerns about these young boys being "outed" by their parents by having their pictures posted on YouTube, blogs, and talk shows. Some commenters wonder why these mothers do not protect their children from ridicule by making them dress in costumes that are more gender appropriate.

The discussion of bullying and suicide over the past few months has seemed to provide a real "teachable moment" for this country. People want to talk about it (as evidenced by the 41,000+ comments on the Nerdy Apple Bottom site). People want to teach kids how to respect themselves and each other. Therefore, they seem fascinated by "My Princess Boy", which uses words and illustrations that can allow even the youngest children to participate in the discussion around personal expression and acceptance. These blogs and books and support from children's schools can really help to change the social norms around what is "normal" behavior and dress. We must be creative in designing a way to evaluate these normative changes. Hopefully we will see a reduction in negative outcomes for students (e.g., reports of bullying, rates of depression, and suicide). But hopefully we will also see a reduction in risk factors further up stream, like attitudes around acceptance and gender roles.